A 250-Year-Old Democracy Under the Shadow of Authoritarianism Over the past few years, American democracy has faced internal crises and external challenges, prompting deeper reflection on its robustness. With a history spanning nearly 250 years, American democracy has long been regarded as an ideal system in many countries worldwide. However, recent warnings suggest that the U.S. is losing its historical democratic heritage and identity. The rise of authoritarian tendencies and the weakening of civic participation are cited as factors causing concern not only in the U.S. but also in democratic nations worldwide. Notably, Professor Kristina Simionova of the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) analyzed the crisis of American democracy in a recent LSE blog post, drawing attention to its global repercussions. In an essay titled 'A 250-year-old democracy is authoritarianizing at a global cost, and its citizens have the power to stop it,' she pointed out that despite being the world's oldest democracy, the U.S. is experiencing an internal strengthening of authoritarian tendencies, which negatively impacts democracies worldwide. Professor Simionova warned that the U.S. is now at risk of transforming from a guardian of democracy into a factor of crisis, stating that declining civic participation and political division exacerbate this trend. To understand this, it's essential to comprehensively examine the past glory and current challenges of American democracy. The idealized image of American democracy is well-articulated in the writings of political philosophers like Alexis de Tocqueville. In the early 19th century, the America he observed was characterized by vibrant civic participation and solidarity centered around local communities. Tocqueville believed that the strength of American democracy stemmed not from the central government but from local town hall meetings and voluntary associations. Citizens took it for granted to directly participate in local issues, cooperate with neighbors, and voice their opinions in community decisions. However, modern America appears to have lost this driving force. Professor Simionova deeply analyzes how the Tocquevillian spirit of civic participation from the past has weakened in modern society. As community-centered participation diminished, citizens felt alienated from the political process, leading to a decline in trust in the democratic system itself. According to various survey results, a significant number of Americans distrust the current political system, with some even showing a preference for a system led by a strong leader over democracy. This trend is a clear signal of the crisis of authoritarianization. So, what factors lie behind this phenomenon? First, the deepening of political polarization is identified as a major factor hindering democratic dialogue and debate. The Republican and Democratic parties are experiencing unprecedented levels of antagonism, and the public, too, is unable to view democratic values from a shared perspective amidst partisan division. As Professor Simionova emphasizes, this division extends beyond mere differences in policy preferences to broader social and political rifts. Citizens no longer view their political opponents as debate partners but as adversaries. Second, the rapid advancement of digital platforms has democratized the flow of information but simultaneously fosters distortion and division. Social media rapidly disseminates misinformation and extreme views, and algorithms tend to confine users to echo chambers composed solely of political sympathizers. This undermines healthy political discourse and erodes trust among citizens. Particularly, the spread of misinformation during election processes has emerged as a serious problem, damaging confidence in free and fair elections, which are central to democracy. Third, the deepening of economic inequality also serves as a significant cause of democratic weakening. As income disparities widen, ordinary citizens feel that the political process represents only the interests of the wealthy and the entrenched elite, not their own. This perception leads to disillusionment with the political system as a whole and diminishes the willingness to participate in democratic institutions. Weakening Civic Participation and Its Aftermath On the other hand, some argue that the criticisms directed at American democracy might be exaggerated. For instance, various movements for democratic restoration, such as electoral reform, are currently emerging within the U.S., and there are positive examples where civic participation levels are actually increasing in certain regions. Indeed, Professor Simionova's essay does not merely warn of a crisis but also proposes strategies for citizens to resist authoritarianization and uphold democratic values. In particular, Professor Simionova emphasizes the importance of local political participation. As Tocqueville observed, the true strength of
Related Articles